Best Mascara
2026
Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara
Sky-high lashes, budget-friendly price
Score 81/100 $10.82
Why this one
Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High delivers professional-level lengthening and volumizing results at just $10.82, earning consistent praise from Reddit users, Amazon reviewers, and beauty experts alike. Its buildable formula and curl-holding power make it a reliable choice for everyday wear, though users should note potential flaking and invest time in careful removal.
Pros
- ✓ Dramatic lengthening and volumizing effects with buildable formula
- ✓ Excellent curl hold throughout the day without smudging
- ✓ Affordable price point with strong drugstore performance
- ✓ No panda eyes or flaking reported by satisfied users
- ✓ Flexible brush creates wispy, separated lashes
Cons
- ✗ Hit-or-miss formula depending on individual lashes and batch consistency
- ✗ Tube dries out quickly, requiring frequent repurchase
- ✗ Difficult and time-consuming removal requiring special techniques
- ✗ Flaking and smudging throughout the day for some users
Our methodology
Based on AI analysis of 177,942 Amazon reviews, Reddit discussions, and expert reviews. Scored 81/100.
Get this one on Amazon →
Price may vary. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.